Doctor Who Cuttings Archive

In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts

From The Doctor Who Cuttings Archive
Jump to navigationJump to search

No image available. However there is a transcription available.

Do you have an image? Email us: whovian@cuttingsarchive.org


[edit]

In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts. Instead, they're 'showrunners' wielding huge power - and their British counterparts aren't far behind, says Andrew Collins

Lords and creators

Arts

During the summer of 2009, 1 hosted a packed Q&A with visiting Americans Damon Lindelof, Carlton Cuse and Jack Bender, at which fans of their long-running ABC drama Lost queued patiently, proffering posters and DVD inserts to be signed and requesting photos. It was as if these middle-aged back-office executives were as famous as Lost's nubile stars. At this moment I began to understand the importance of "showrunners" in the imagination of US audiences.

The "showrunner" has achieved cult status in America, thanks to our ever-deepening appreciation of how TV works, through fansites and box-set extras, brand loyalty to long-running franchises nurtured at fan conventions such as San Diego's Comic-Con, and the global watercooler of social media. (While Bender was busy shooting in Hawaii, Lindelof and Cuse appeared on ABC's official Lost pod cast, forging a direct link with the geeks through self-deprecating in-jokery.)

In an ever-shrinking TV world of co-productions, US terminology is creeping into the British TV drama conversation, arguably muddying the distinction between the more industrial production infrastructure of the 23-episode US network behemoth and our own "authored" tradition of TV fiction. Because who wants to be thought of as simply "the writer", hovering like a spare part behind the monitor, when you can be elevated, semantically, to "showrunner"?

Entertainment orthodoxy states that film is a director's medium and TV is a writer's medium. Increasingly, TV is a showrunner's medium. It's an appealingly blunt job description that bespeaks supreme executive power. "It's not accurate, of course," says Chris Chibnall, who "show-ran" ITV's appointment-to-view whodunnit Broadchurch, as well as Law & Order: UK and Camelot. 'Any drama is the product of a team." More of an industry term than a credit - as it's never used onscreen - showrunning is, he says, really about "the writer having a voice throughout the process, not just handing over a script". He refers to Mark Catley's recent stint as write r-pro ducerconsultant on Casualty as an experimental example that "utterly reinvigorated that show".

By my reckoning, the concept initially crept over the Atlantic in 1999 when Fred Barron, a seasoned writer-producer on Larry Sanders and Caroline in the City, launched the sitcom My Family, with a large, American-style writing staff. (The vulgar notion must have appalled Roy Clarke, who wrote all 295 episodes of Last of the Summer Wine.) But it was Russell T Davies who popularised it when he took control of the rebooted Doctor Who brand in 2003. At the end of his reign in 2009, he coyly described his role to Mark Lawson as "that sort of American 'showrunner' position", but provided a helpful job description: "To establish the tone of the show." His successor, Steven Moffat, is probably British telly's best known showrunner. Total control... from left, Joss Whedor, Vince Gilligan aid Russel T Davies. Below, crime drama Broadchurch.

This is an edited list of Chibnall's duties: "I'm across every piece of casting; sign off designs; approve location choices; I watch rushes, assemblies, cuts; give notes; work with the director and editor on each episode; work with director of photography to set the right grade for the series, the colour palette ..." It goes on and on, right through to publicity. Dennis Waterman-style, he even wrote the theme tune - well, the lyrics to Ólafur Arnalds's end song. "The showrunner needs to be the voice, the reference point, the vision."

Michael Oates Palmer, staff writer on The West Wing, applied less reverence when he said: "They're the ringmaster, the elephant tamer and the people who clean the cages."

At last month's Guardian Edinburgh TV festival, a "masterclass" with unassuming, downhome Breaking Bad creator Vince Gilligan was the biggest draw. In a forthcoming, illuminating feature from Irish film-maker Des Doyle, the Kickstarter-funded Showrunners: A Documentary Film, the august likes of Joss Whedon (Buffy and soon-to-air Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.), Shawn Ryan (The Shield) and Terence Winter (Boardwalk Empire) take centre stage, with Spartacus's Steven S DeKnight describing a panel at Comic-Con being "a little bit like a rock concert".

You can see why British writers might hanker after such superstar status. But do we really need it in British drama? Dennis Potter was never a showrunner. Troy Kennedy-Martin didn't exec-produce Edge of Darkness. Isn't this just another example of us emulating the Yanks, showing off by saying "season" for "series", and "sizzle reel" for "trailer"?

After all, they do things differently there. Compare the credits of current gothic ITV procedural Whitechapel and Channel Five's high-concept US import Under the Dome. The former lists one producer and two writers (the show's creators, Ben Court and Caroline Ip); the latter, one writer, three producers, two co-producers, one co-executive producer and eight executive producers. Such a large circus cries out for a ringmaster.

Chibnall thinks our adoption of the showrunning ethic can improve British TV by "putting the creative vision at the heart of a show". He refers to the first scene shot in the police interview room in Broadchurch, which was "essentially a square box. I'd wanted windows and a curve to connect the interior and exterior worlds, so that we could have all kinds of light variations. An extra wall was added in. As a writer, I wouldn't have had that clout - as a showrunner, I do."


TV JARGON: US v UK

What they say What we say

Network TV Terrestrial TV

Cable Satellite

Teleplay Script

Nielsen ratings BARB ratings

Season Series

Miniseries Series

Air date TX

Showrunner Chief writer

Executive Producer Writer (or lead actor, in lieu of payrise)

Writers' Room Caffe Nero

Cancelled Shunted to 10.30 slot

Sizzle reel Trailer

Spot Advert

Talk show Chat show

Disclaimer: These citations are created on-the-fly using primitive parsing techniques. You should double-check all citations. Send feedback to whovian@cuttingsarchive.org

  • APA 6th ed.: Collins, Andrew (2013-09-16). In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts. The Guardian p. 18.
  • MLA 7th ed.: Collins, Andrew. "In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts." The Guardian [add city] 2013-09-16, 18. Print.
  • Chicago 15th ed.: Collins, Andrew. "In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts." The Guardian, edition, sec., 2013-09-16
  • Turabian: Collins, Andrew. "In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts." The Guardian, 2013-09-16, section, 18 edition.
  • Wikipedia (this article): <ref>{{cite news| title=In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts | url=http://cuttingsarchive.org/index.php/In_America,_TV_writers_are_no_longer_made_to_feel_like_spare_parts | work=The Guardian | pages=18 | date=2013-09-16 | via=Doctor Who Cuttings Archive | accessdate=29 March 2024 }}</ref>
  • Wikipedia (this page): <ref>{{cite web | title=In America, TV writers are no longer made to feel like spare parts | url=http://cuttingsarchive.org/index.php/In_America,_TV_writers_are_no_longer_made_to_feel_like_spare_parts | work=Doctor Who Cuttings Archive | accessdate=29 March 2024}}</ref>