Doctor Who Cuttings Archive

Let's not be beastly to Daleks

From The Doctor Who Cuttings Archive
Jump to navigationJump to search
The Times coverage of series 1date
BBC canned HD deal for Doctor Who2005-03-01
Interview with Kate Orman: Dr Who Author2005-03-01
The Doctor will see you now ...2005-03-01
Alehouse Rock2005-03-01
For 25 years, Doctor Who's creaky charm captivated a nation2005-03-06
Elevate, exterminate: Daleks conquer stairs in new Doctor Who2005-03-06
The thrill of the chaise2005-03-06
What's Up Doc? (The Observer)2005-03-06
Quick! Behind the sofa!2005-03-07
Let's hope Time Lord Christopher Eccleston is happy with his performance2005-03-07
Exterbinate!2005-03-08
Net pirates steal preview of Doctor Who comeback2005-03-08
New Doctor Who show leaked on the internet2005-03-08
The Doctor faces his newest adversary ... the Canadians2005-03-09
Carry on Doctor (Time Out London)2005-03-09
Eccleston and Billie, just what the Doctor ordered2005-03-09
The good doctor2005-03-09
BBC hopes for a rescue by Doctor Who2005-03-09
Top of the docs2005-03-09
Billie plots return to pop2005-03-09
Doctor Who puts accent on a new look to old show2005-03-10
Doctor Who And A Scary £10m Gamble2005-03-10
Doctor Who Whodunit2005-03-10
Flying Daleks and Hollywood-style special effects as BBC aims to get families cowering behind sofas again with revival of TV series2005-03-10
Doctor Who leak previews future of broadcast content2005-03-10
Who's a bit camp2005-03-10
Dr Who save my life says Billie Piper2005-03-10
Who's who of monsters2005-03-10
See Who Jimmy2005-03-10
Why can't daleks go up stairs?2005-03-10
Who are you staring at?2005-03-10
Forgotten timelord2005-03-11
Who's who?2005-03-12
Everyone has a favourite Doctor Who as a matter of accident of birth, not of taste2005-03-12
Carry On Doctor2005-03-13
Billie Bardot2005-03-13
Another dimension2005-03-14
Doctor Who's new assistant2005-03-14
Media Tarts2005-03-14
Tom Baker voted top Doctor2005-03-14
Just what the Doctor ordered (2005)2005-03-17
The Doctor goes space age2005-03-17
The Return of the Time Lord2005-03-18
Billie the kid2005-03-19
Who said what?2005-03-19
The A-Z of Doctor Who2005-03-19
It's properly scary and funny2005-03-19
What Makes Who Special2005-03-19
A tale of British boffins2005-03-19
Radio choice2005-03-19
I've Fallen for a Dalek2005-03-19
Who?2005-03-19
A Time Lord Timeline2005-03-19
Billie's big comeback?2005-03-19
My sweet Time Lord: Are Sixties Daleks worth anything?2005-03-20
The Doctor's Darlings2005-03-20
What's Up Doc?2005-03-20
Dr Who: talking about my generation2005-03-20
Doctor New (Sunday Life)2005-03-20
Who Dunnit Once ... but can cult sci-fi classic save BBC again?2005-03-21
I chased an actor dressed up as an alien pig on my first day ... it was bonkers2005-03-21
Carry on Doctor (The Guardian)2005-03-21
Rhodri Who? Minister mistaken for alien2005-03-21
Chris Eccleston and I have shared a lot2005-03-21
Billie and I have on-screen chemistry2005-03-21
I don't regret leaving The Street2005-03-21
Piper at the gates of dim2005-03-21
Doctor Who (2005)2005-03-22
Inside the Tardis2005-03-22
Who's the baddy!2005-03-22
Ex-singer is taking on aliens2005-03-22
Doctor Boo!2005-03-23
In short, I have a vanishingly small part in the new run of Doctor Who2005-03-23
The Who-Sual Suspects2005-03-23
Dr Who's Who2005-03-23
Doctor Who: funny he never married ...2005-03-24
Who's this in a dogs' home?2005-03-24
Looka-Yikes2005-03-24
A new Who does it2005-03-24
Who's That Girl (2005)2005-03-24
Timely return2005-03-24
Sexterminate! Sexterminate!2005-03-24
Time Lord's floozy - there's no future in that, Billie2005-03-24
The Great Doctor Who Quiz2005-03-25
Doc foe dies of old age2005-03-25
I fear future as the Timelord, admits Dr Who2005-03-25
Enter the trendy new Doctor Who2005-03-25
The Whys and Whats of Who2005-03-26
Blonde Bombshell2005-03-26
Piper calls the tune2005-03-26
Mr TARDIS2005-03-26
Who's the daddy?2005-03-26
The effects2005-03-26
The creatures2005-03-26
Bring on those nightmares!2005-03-26
Oh, My Time Lord2005-03-26
Return of the Daleks2005-03-26
Doctor Who returns2005-03-26
It's about Time (The Northern Echo)2005-03-26
The sexiest Time Lord yet2005-03-26
Doctor Who arrives in modern times. And it works2005-03-26
Your handy cut-out guide to the greatest day on telly - ever2005-03-26
The BBC has no qualms about reviving old series2005-03-26
Best Regeneration2005-03-26
One of the scariest programmes (if you're eight years old)2005-03-26
Children can't say they've had a proper upbringing until they've spent a Saturday evening hiding behind the sofa with one eye on Doctor Who2005-03-26
A timely return for the Doctor2005-03-26
The prognosis for feminism is not good2005-03-26
That's the wonder of Who...2005-03-26
Dalektable!2005-03-26
Older time-travellers left on different planet2005-03-26
Heroes & Villains2005-03-26
The Who Was Who in Dr Who2005-03-26
Doctor faces a high-tech challenge2005-03-26
Watch This2005-03-26
Who dares..2005-03-26
He's no dummy2005-03-26
Doctor in the house!2005-03-26
Doctor in Love2005-03-26
Lording it2005-03-26
Who's the greatest!2005-03-26
The Doctor Will See You Now...2005-03-26
Corrie's Tricky Dicky is most chilling TV clip2005-03-26
Oh Lord, he's still stuck in the past2005-03-27
Your worst nightmare .. new Daleks that can go UPSTAIRS!2005-03-27
Who the man..new Doc is wheelie cool2005-03-27
Now All-Out Dalek War2005-03-27
Doc's grin and tonic2005-03-27
BBC cashes in as new Doctor hits the screens2005-03-27
Doctor prescribes a cure for Beeb's terminal misery2005-03-27
Can Doctor Who Dec Ant?2005-03-27
Just what the Doctor ordered2005-03-28
Who's the daddy as 10m find time to see the Doctor2005-03-28
Run for your life2005-03-28
Ten million welcome back the Doctor2005-03-28
Express Charts2005-03-28
Who's the daddy (The Sun)2005-03-28
Dr Who wins Saturday night TV ratings war2005-03-28
This Doctor is the right prescription2005-03-28
10million watch the new Dr Who2005-03-28
Jason Flemyng2005-03-29
The Right Medicine?2005-03-30
The Daleks Tried, The Cybermen Tried ... But It Finally Took A N.Wales Gardener To Destroy The Tardis2005-03-30
New Dr Who let down by same old cheesy effects2005-03-30
We'll Exterminate All the Other Toys2005-03-30
Prepare for an invasion of the Dr Who toys2005-03-30
Canadian TV worker fired for leaking Doctor Who2005-03-30
Graham Norton on Dr Who? That is scary2005-03-30
I quit as Dr Who2005-03-31
He saves the world and BBC, then Dr Who quits2005-03-31
Doctor Woo2005-03-31
Doctor Who Quits2005-03-31
Who better to win the battle2005-03-31
Dr Who star makes way for Casanova2005-03-31
Dr Who star says time's up2005-03-31
BBC's anger at the vanishing Doctor Who2005-04-01
Casanova actor seduces the Doctor Who casting agent2005-04-01
How Casanova made his next conquest a dalek2005-04-01
Greg's giggle2005-04-01
Who It All Again2005-04-01
I am not Spock: how some actors never manage to escape from their most famous characters2005-04-01
And the date of the election is ...2005-04-01
Who do you think you are?2005-04-01
Feeling like a completely new man2005-04-01
Is it all over for planet Earth?2005-04-01
I thought it was just me who was convinced that doctors are getting younger2005-04-01
Who's Who (2005)2005-04-01
Origin of species2005-04-02
Carry on, Doctor Who2005-04-02
The Doctor returns2005-04-02
Doctoring the results2005-04-02
Dr Who-Ha2005-04-02
Dr Who Website In Meltdown2005-04-02
Who's in a £50m Mess2005-04-02
The Hit Sci-Fi Series is Back2005-04-02
Are diehard fans ready for a modern Doctor Who?2005-04-02
Dr Who Told Beeb He'd Stay In Show2005-04-03
Mystery man returns2005-04-03
Who Cares If Time Lord Leaves Early?2005-04-04
Dr. Who wants to see you—again2005-04-04
Tree's a crowd2005-04-04
Dr Who viewers fall 2.6m2005-04-04
Forget the laughs, Doc, give us fear2005-04-04
Just look who's on the slide2005-04-04
Canada hears a Who2005-04-05
BBC says sorry to new Dr Who over typecasting claim2005-04-05
Who's back. And Who's looking vastly entertaining2005-04-05
Rose in kidnap2005-04-06
Doctor new2005-04-07
Doctor in tune with past2005-04-07
Meet the Next P.M. ... and he's full of hot air like Blair2005-04-07
Letters2005-04-09
Their mutual friend2005-04-09
Billie's new role as Chris backs an Idiot2005-04-10
Rose2005-04-11
Twisting the night away2005-04-11
The traveller in time2005-04-11
Who broke Big Ben?2005-04-13
Billie Pins Down Celeb Wrestlers2005-04-13
Dr Who too scary for young children2005-04-14
Doctor Who is too scary for children2005-04-14
Who-ray! the doctor is in2005-04-14
BBC climbs down over Doctor Who fear factor2005-04-15
Too frightening for parents?2005-04-15
Close encounters2005-04-15
Destroy Ant and Dec!2005-04-15
Killing time2005-04-16
Casanova regenerates into the new Doctor Who2005-04-16
Casanova's next conquest is the Tardis2005-04-16
David's the new Doc2005-04-16
Wild about the boy2005-04-16
Today's TV with Mike Ward2005-04-16
Casanova Will Be the New Dr Who2005-04-16
Political prisoners2005-04-16
She's out of this world2005-04-16
Alison Graham On... Who's The Doctor2005-04-16
Beam me up, scotty! There's klingons on the seafront2005-04-18
More outrage as Dr Who 'crucified'2005-04-18
Your View: Doctor Always Was A Thriller2005-04-19
Who's Afraid?2005-04-19
Doctor Who brought back to life in new series2005-04-19
Who knew Doctor Who revival would be so good?2005-04-19
Doctor Who gets 10th face2005-04-20
This is a wind up2005-04-20
A Famous Dram For The New Dr Who2005-04-22
The face of evil?2005-04-23
Fair and square2005-04-23
Nigel Andrew's View2005-04-23
World war2005-04-23
Flight Of The Dalek2005-04-24
Who's who in pop's Tardis2005-04-24
Dr Who in kilt Scot my vote2005-04-24
Dr Who's T-Rusted Sidekick2005-04-25
Dr Who gets political2005-04-25
Exterminate Chris!2005-04-25
Chris Eccleston explains why he left Dr Who2005-04-26
Shocker for Doc2005-04-26
Posh 'n Becks crisis--latest2005-04-26
I Wanted to Exterminate the Daleks2005-04-26
Doctor Feud2005-04-26
Daleks v Girls on Girls Action2005-04-27
Bruno goes from Todd to the Tardis2005-04-27
Rovers' returns2005-04-29
Give the man a BAFTA2005-04-29
Tinpot dictator2005-04-30
Quickie...2005-04-30
Gwen Stefani must be a secret fan of Doctor Who2005-04-30
It's just out of this world!2005-04-30
From Gay to Geek2005-04-30
Exterminate! Exterminate!2005-04-30
Reader Rant2005-04-30
Keep us hanging on ...2005-04-30
Cheapskaaates2005-04-30
Doctor's deadliest enemy2005-04-30
Inventor of Daleks only earned £80!!!2005-04-30
Exterminate the Wrestlers2005-04-30
So, the story we've all been waiting for2005-04-30
This is what we've been waiting for2005-04-30
Be afraid, be very afraid... The Daleks are coming back to a living room near you!2005-04-30
Return of the Daleks!2005-04-30
D-aargh-lek's wimpy ending2005-05-01
Carry On, Doctor2005-05-01
The softer side of the sole remaining Dalek2005-05-02
Back behind the sofa — it's a Dalek2005-05-02
£2m sales for the man who makes Daleks2005-05-02
Dalek Roy Yearns To Obey Orders2005-05-02
Exhumate! Exhumate!2005-05-02
Daleks exterminate wrestlers2005-05-03
BBC apologises to Dr Who2005-05-04
Cameo role for Pegg in Dr Who2005-05-04
Trust invaded by zombies, pigs and walking dummies2005-05-05
Wanted: One Time Lord, Tardis optional2005-05-06
The naked Dalek2005-05-07
Free Doctor Who and Friends CD inside today plus bonus Star Wars track2005-05-07
It takes three ...2005-05-07
Today's TV with Mike Ward (2005-05-07)2005-05-07
A grave future is awaiting the Doctor Who2005-05-08
Dr Who's new enemy: Star Wars!2005-05-11
Unholy terror2005-05-14
The galactic cardboard fantasy sets exterminated as a sexy new doctor materialises on our television screens time for fans old and new to find out who is who2005-05-14
Doctor Phew!2005-05-14
A well-crafted machine2005-05-14
Adding a soul to The Doctor's two hearts2005-05-14
From Daleks To Dracula!2005-05-15
Let's not be beastly to Daleks2005-05-16
An absurd ruling takes the fun out of Doctor Who2005-05-16
Unsuitable for children2005-05-17
The censors ... will ... exterminate2005-05-17
The Daleks in my bedroom2005-05-18
Dr Who skull cracking is cut2005-05-18
Doctor treated2005-05-19
Legislate! Legislate!2005-05-19
Streaming for more?2005-05-19
Hamlet2005-05-19
Brits Still Enjoying 'Doctor Who' Antics2005-05-20
It helps to be a Time Lord2005-05-20
Dreams and Nightmares2005-05-21
A doctor so sexy it's scary2005-05-21
The timely Doctor Who saves family audience Daleks make a welcome return to the living room2005-05-21
Being true to Dr Who2005-05-22
Beeb exterminates Dr Who DVD plans2005-05-22
Billie: It's Ta-ta to the Tardis2005-05-23
Who's the daddy (The Stage)2005-05-26
Tranter promises more family drama on weekend2005-05-26
Who's a lucky devil2005-05-26
To be continued...2005-05-28
Just what the 'Doctor Who' ordered2005-05-28
Time Lord travelling again, this time to the stage2005-05-31
Time teamer2005-06-02
I'm Trapped in Crash Wreck ... Tape Dr Who!2005-06-02
The BBC have zapped new life into that most bizarre of geek entertainments, Dr. Who2005-06-02
Boom Town2005-06-03
What's next, Doc?2005-06-04
Death of the Doctor2005-06-04
Colin checks out Who wears what2005-06-04
Reality can be a killer2005-06-11
Geoffrey Toone2005-06-12
BBC advises Doctor Who fans to stay offline until the bitter end2005-06-14
Sought, located2005-06-15
The Doctor's fate is sealed with a first kiss — or two2005-06-16
Who Lets The Dog Out2005-06-18
They're back ... and this time it's war!2005-06-18
Doctor Ooooh!2005-06-18
Time up for Chris2005-06-18
Do catch the last in the current series of Dr Who2005-06-18
Doctor Who's greatest triumph - the return of TV for all the family2005-06-20
Local voices for local people2005-06-20
Silly Billie just lost the plot2005-06-22
Series 3 for Who2005-06-24
I'm prepared for my role as BBC Man, but how to fit Big Specs into the new Dr Who?2005-06-25
Awkward squad2005-06-27
Saturday night fever2005-06-27
Soundbites2005-07-01
Doctor who? (Idea)2005-07-01

2005-05-16 Times p3.jpg

[edit]

Censors say children should not learn to admire cruelty against Doctor Who's mortal enemy, writes Adam Sherwin


CENSORS have banned young children from buying the new series of Doctor Who on video or DVD on the grounds of "excessive cruelty" towards a Dalek.

The British Board of Film Classification has refined a PG certificate to the series because of torture techniques applied to the Time Lord's mortal enemy. Censors ruled that the sequence sets a bad example to children because it implies that the only way to resolve disputes is through force allied with cruelty. A spokesman for the board said: "However cross one might be with a Dalek, being cruel is not the way to deal with the issue. Some children might take it into the playground."

Shops cannot sell the DVD to children under the age of 12. The same restriction applies to an episode featuring Victorian killer zombies, which attracted complaints from 100 parents after it was screened on BBC One. The BBC expects the Doctor Who DVDs to become an international hit and a wave of merchandise will hit stores before Christmas.

The first DVD, which includes another controversial episode, The Unquiet Dead, is to be released today. Fans will pay about £100 for the complete collection, including a Tardis-packaged boxed set.

Dalek will be released in June but the BBC will not cut the episode for children. It depicts the last Dalek in the universe imprisoned and chained by a billionaire, who tortures the creature with drills. The Doctor taunts the impotent Dalek, boasting that he has wiped out its race.

But he is also terrified and demands that the weakened Dalek be killed in his lust for revenge. The Dalek eventually kills itself after acquiring human traits.

These scenes set a bad example, censors ruled. A spokesman said: "We were concerned at the use of violence to resolve problems. The Doctor is a role model for young children but he takes out his anger on the Dalek. A good role model should not use torture to satisfy his desire for revenge. It is not an acceptable way to deal with problems of power. The DVD must not be supplied to anyone under the age of 12."

The BBC has previously said that Doctor Who was not suitable for viewers under the age of eight, before changing its mind during the furore surrounding The Unquiet Dead. Censors said that the supernatural element of that episode, in which a coffin-bound dead woman strangles her grandson, would be "unsettling" for under-12s because the tone was darker than the Doctor's traditional escapades. Under the board's rating system, 12-rated DVDs are allowed "sustained, moderate threat and menace. Occasional gory moments only". A PG is awarded to films and programmes that "should not disturb a child aged around eight or older".

The return of Doctor Who has been a major hit for BBC One and obliterated its Saturday-night competition when it was launched two months ago. It has secured around 7.5 million viewers a week. ITV1 has pulled Celebrity Wrestling — its latest challenger — off screens after just four weeks. The BBC is selling the new Doctor Who to international broadcasters and has signed up David Tennant to replace Christopher Eccleston next year.


Nightmares? Just a part of growing up

By Daniel McGrory

THE censors watched The Lord of the Rings half a dozen times before they agreed to give the film a tame PG certificate. Members of the British Board of Film Classification conceded that there was as a huge amount of violence, but as "fantasy beasts" were on the receiving end and not human beings children of any age could see it if their parents allowed. In their rule book, mutilating Orcs was all right. Clearly the censors feel more protective about Daleks.

Torturing Daleks now joins racism, suicide and explicit sex on the board's list of things that pre-adolescent children should not see. This ruling marks a shift for the censors, who have been accused of surrendering to playground power in the past in allowing under-12s to watch violent films. In 2002 children, angered that they could not see Spider-Man, badgered the board to revamp its 12 category. The censors reluctantly introduced the 12A label which meant that children of any age could see the film if they went with an adult.

David Cooke, the new director of the board, is refusing to budge on dropping the "kiddy classification" altogether, saying child protection is the key to new guidelines on permitting smoking, racism or controversial scenes such as suicide to be seen on screen. He says that they consult medical experts and psychiatrists before ruling what under-12s should see. Defending the board against claims that it has become too relaxed, Mr Cook said that more than 10 per cent of films were given a higher classification than the one the producers requested. A European Commission investigation says Britain is the most censorious country in Europe after Ireland.

In 1975, when considering Jaws, James Ferman, the board's former president, consulted a psychiatrist over whether sharks eating human beings 'would give children nightmares. The psychiatrist said: "What is so bad about nightmares? It's just kids working through their problems."

Is this a case of nanny knows best?

Send your a-mails to debate@thetimes.co.uk


Caption: Rose, played by Billy Piper, refuses to be unkind to the last remaining Dalek, which has been imprisoned and tortured with drills

Disclaimer: These citations are created on-the-fly using primitive parsing techniques. You should double-check all citations. Send feedback to whovian@cuttingsarchive.org

  • APA 6th ed.: Sherwin, Adam (2005-05-16). Let's not be beastly to Daleks. The Times p. 3.
  • MLA 7th ed.: Sherwin, Adam. "Let's not be beastly to Daleks." The Times [add city] 2005-05-16, 3. Print.
  • Chicago 15th ed.: Sherwin, Adam. "Let's not be beastly to Daleks." The Times, edition, sec., 2005-05-16
  • Turabian: Sherwin, Adam. "Let's not be beastly to Daleks." The Times, 2005-05-16, section, 3 edition.
  • Wikipedia (this article): <ref>{{cite news| title=Let's not be beastly to Daleks | url=http://cuttingsarchive.org/index.php/Let%27s_not_be_beastly_to_Daleks | work=The Times | pages=3 | date=2005-05-16 | via=Doctor Who Cuttings Archive | accessdate=15 October 2024 }}</ref>
  • Wikipedia (this page): <ref>{{cite web | title=Let's not be beastly to Daleks | url=http://cuttingsarchive.org/index.php/Let%27s_not_be_beastly_to_Daleks | work=Doctor Who Cuttings Archive | accessdate=15 October 2024}}</ref>